Cast of My Fault London – Full Actors List and Roles

Amazon MGM Studios prepares to launch My Fault: London on February 13, 2025, presenting a British reimagining of the 2023 Spanish romantic drama. The film adapts Mercedes Ron’s novel Culpa mía with an entirely new ensemble led by Asha Banks and Matthew Broome, shifting the setting from Madrid to the United Kingdom while maintaining the core narrative of two young people navigating a complicated attraction.

Directed by Charlotte Fassler and Dani Girdwood, this version separates itself from Domingo González’s original through complete recasting. Rather than functioning as a narrative sequel, the production stands as a standalone interpretation produced by the company 42, with Ben Pugh and Erica Steinberg overseeing development for Prime Video distribution.

The cast comprises more than twenty-five performers across principal and supporting roles, reflecting the story’s expansion into British cultural contexts while preserving the source material’s dramatic tension between the McKay and Leister families.

Who Is in the Cast of My Fault: London?

The central romantic pairing features Asha Banks portraying Noah and Matthew Broome as Nick, with both actors leading an ensemble that includes established British screen veterans and emerging talent.

Key Casting Insights

• Asha Banks and Matthew Broome assume the lead roles originally performed by Spanish actors in the 2023 version.
• The production maintains character names and family structures from Mercedes Ron’s novel while relocating the narrative to London.
• Supporting players include Jason Flemyng and Ray Fearon in patriarchal roles.
• Executive producers include Domingo González, who wrote and directed the original Spanish film.
• Melissa Osborne adapted the screenplay for this British version.
• The cast list encompasses twenty-five credited performers across speaking and background roles.
• Prime Video serves as the exclusive streaming platform for the February 2025 debut.

Principal Cast and Characters

Returning Stars from the Original My Fault

Despite speculation surrounding continuity with the 2023 Spanish production, starring Nicole Wallace and Gabriel Guevara, official sources confirm that no cast members from the original film appear in the London remake. This creative decision establishes the British version as a distinct interpretation rather than a narrative continuation.

Original Cast Absence

Wallace and Guevara, who portrayed Noah and Nick in the Madrid-set original, remain unmentioned in all casting documentation for the 2025 adaptation. The remake instead opts for complete recasting, allowing Fassler and Girdwood to establish new on-screen dynamics without obligations to previous performances.

Implications for Narrative Continuity

This separation suggests the London version may alter specific plot points or character details from Ron’s novel while maintaining the central romance. The absence of original stars indicates viewers need no familiarity with the 2023 film to follow the 2025 narrative, positioning it as an entry point for new audiences.

New Faces and Supporting Cast in My Fault: London

Beyond the central couple, the production introduces an extensive supporting network portraying family members, friends, and antagonists. Character databases identify twenty-three additional credited roles filling out the social world of the Leister and McKay families.

Notable Supporting Performers

Eve Macklin appears as Ella, while Enva Lewis portrays Jenna. Sam Buchanan takes the role of Ronnie Burns, and Kerim Hassan plays Lion. These characters presumably represent Noah and Nick’s respective social circles, driving the interpersonal conflicts central to the young adult drama genre.

Extended Ensemble Members

The cast further includes Sekou Diaby as Zach, Tommy Belshaw as Giles, George Robinson as JP, and Tallulah Evans as Haley. Rounding out the ensemble are Seosaimhin Hennelly (Maddie), Fiona Marr (Detective Sato), and Gerard Monaco (Martin), among others contributing to the film’s London setting.

Key Roles and Characters Played by the Cast

Character names largely follow Ron’s source material, though some variations appear in casting documentation. The narrative centers on the relationship between Noah McKay, a young woman adjusting to new family dynamics, and Nick Leister, her soon-to-be stepbrother with a complicated reputation.

The Protagonists

Asha Banks portrays Noah McKay (sometimes referenced simply as Noah), the audience’s primary perspective into the wealthy Leister world. Matthew Broome plays Nick Leister (also listed as Nick), whose public image as a problematic wealthy youth conceals more vulnerable aspects revealed through the romantic plot.

Family Dynamics

Ray Fearon appears as William Leister, the father figure connecting the two leads through marriage. Jason Flemyng portrays Travis McKay, presumably Noah’s father, establishing the parental tensions that drive Noah’s relocation and subsequent involvement with the Leister family. Amelia Kenworthy appears as Anna Wolfe-Barnes, suggesting additional family complexity.

Associates and Antagonists

Harry Gilby appears as Dan, while Christina Cole plays Bethan. The presence of a Detective Sato (Fiona Marr) suggests narrative elements involving legal or criminal complications, potentially relating to racing or burglary subplots referenced in the source material.

Director and Production Team Behind My Fault: London

Charlotte Fassler and Dani Girdwood share directing duties, marking a collaborative vision for the adaptation. Production records indicate the project falls under the 42 banner, with Ben Pugh and Erica Steinberg producing.

Writing and Adaptation

Melissa Osborne receives screenplay credit for translating Ron’s novel into the British context. Domingo González, who wrote and directed the original Spanish film, serves as an executive producer alongside Álex de la Iglesia, Carolina Bang, and Kari Hatfield, providing continuity between the two versions despite the separate casts.

Technical Credits

Ed Moore operates as Director of Photography, while James Jacob composes the original score. The crew includes Gemma Hoff as hair designer and stunt coordination by Rachael Evelyn and Aidan Brindle, suggesting action sequences involving the racing or combat elements present in the novel.

Production Timeline and Release Schedule

1. 2023: The original Spanish-language My Fault premieres, establishing the franchise.
2. Development: Amazon MGM Studios commissions a British remake with Fassler and Girdwood attached.
3. Casting: Asha Banks and Matthew Broome confirmed as leads, with supporting ensemble assembled.
4. February 13, 2025: My Fault: London releases exclusively on Prime Video.

Confirmed Information versus Addressed Rumors

From Madrid to London: The Adaptation Context

The transition from the 2023 Spanish film to the 2025 British version represents a growing trend in transnational young adult adaptations, where successful stories receive culturally specific remakes rather than dubbed or subtitled distribution. By relocating the action to London and engaging British performers like Fearon and Flemyng, the production attempts to capture the class dynamics and urban environments specific to the United Kingdom while maintaining the universal themes of forbidden romance and family integration that drove the original’s popularity.

This approach allows the narrative to explore distinctly British settings—potentially involving London’s racing circuits or affluent neighborhoods—while keeping the core emotional conflicts intact. The decision to exclude the original stars, despite their popularity, reinforces the remake’s status as a separate artistic interpretation rather than a franchise continuation.

Official Sources and Production Verification

Casting information draws from multiple verified databases including Wikipedia, MovieMeter, and TV Guide, with cross-referencing against the Culpable Fandom wiki and Rotten Tomatoes crew listings. These sources consistently report the same principal and supporting cast without variation in the lead roles.

“The 2025 British romantic drama film directed by Charlotte Fassler and Dani Girdwood serves as a remake of the 2023 Spanish film.”

— Culpable Fandom Wiki and Wikipedia verification

“No sources mention Nicole Wallace or Gabriel Guevara, who starred in the original 2023 Spanish My Fault.”

— Casting verification across multiple databases

My Fault: London Cast Summary

My Fault: London introduces Asha Banks and Matthew Broome as Noah and Nick, supported by an ensemble of over twenty-five performers including Eve Macklin, Ray Fearon, and Jason Flemyng. The complete cast replacement from the 2023 Spanish original positions this February 2025 Prime Video release as a distinct British interpretation of Mercedes Ron’s novel, directed by Charlotte Fassler and Dani Girdwood for Amazon MGM Studios. Those interested in British ensemble casts may also appreciate the Shameless (British TV Series) Guide for comparative context on UK dramatic performances.

Frequently Asked Questions